do you think Demon's Souls deserves the extra point?!

[Ssenkahdavic]

Lurker said:

ocnkng said:
There was a time during the release of this game that I used to check metacritic every hour, hoping and praying that this game gets to AAA. It was at 91 for a long time actually. Till some late reviews pulled it down. IMO the failure to give 90+ to this game marked one of the biggest failure of the whole review system.

A couple sites gave it low scores because it was too hard for them to even finish probably. Just laugh at them.

Why data should be handled like we have to at work.  We always drop the Lowest/Highest pieces of data before we do our averages (1 or more high/low depending on how much data).  Would have made it 90+ which it definitely deserves.