mmm.. i have to disagree on that point, i remember the first time i played Nintendogs on 2005, by that time i didnt knew much about the DS i wasnt as much into videogaming news and stuff as i am right now, the game simply blew me away, it was completely unexpected at that time i considered myself a hardcore, i spent my days playing Starcraft if memory serves me well... the game was brilliant i didnt expect 3D graphics on a portable console (i didnt knew much about the PSP either i was exceptical about it as ive always been with everything with Sony on it) , the touch screen reacted perfectly, the microphone did so too, and who cares! playing with the cute dogs was fun *.*, taking them to walk and training them everyday, taking them into tournaments, washing them everything seemed completely different from anything before.
I think its an experience that completely exploted the DS capabilities, a Wii version would be weird... the only fun part would be throwing the frisbee and we already did that on WSR, i think Eyepet is closer to Nintendogs than any pet game that could be made on the Wii and yet it doesnt get close to Nintendogs
Nintendo is the best videogames company ever!
