Should homosexuals be executed? The BBC wants to know.

[pearljammer]

Carl2291 said:

tombi123 said:

Carl2291 said:

tombi123 said:

Carl2291 said:

Peado is not a race.

Peadophiles usually have other mental issues and should be put in a mental institution and given help, not executed. 

Plus if you start executing peado's and not murderers, then the peadophile might kill the child afterwards to escape being executed.

Peados dont deserve any kind of help.

Peados who murder the kid too should be executed... Slowly. 

But how would you know the murderer also had sex with the kid. 

And people with mental issues DO deserve help.

The same way people find out everything else to do with murders and all that stuff? Forensics? Etc...

Debatable, depending on there actions. But if you want to offer help to someone who murders and abuses kids, then you are a very strange person.

That's  an absurd thing to say. You can't just say that anyone who legitimately feels different than you on remediation is a very strange person.

Do I feel like they should be punished? Yes, with every fibre of my being. Believe me, I do. Are they likely to have something seriously wrong with themselves? Probably. I mean, we don't know the lives these people have had. Perhaps if, in some cases, we had had the same life we possibly could have turned out the same?

But I do agree with you to some extent. To a degree it may depend on their actions, though I'd put far more weight into their reasons.

Anyhow, on topic: I'm with Kasz on this one; BBC has every right to debate this... though I certainly don't think it'd much of a debate...