Contoller/Console better for FPS than KB+Mouse/PC?!?

[Reasonable]

max power said:
The ONLY argument I've ever heard in favor of controller that makes sense, is that with the controller, an analog stick will offer better movement options than fixed keys. This is true, but the fact that aiming is so much better with a mouse than the other analog stick completely negates any benefits.

Anyway, M/KB >>> Dual analog. Did you explain to your family member that console FPS's have auto-aim to make up for the shitty controls?

You're quite correct.  In run and gun titles the accuracy and speed of response advantage outweighs running all the time, but for titles like Fallout 3 or Oblivion analogue movement is better.

I actually think the best control scheme for a pure shooter (i.e. nothing that needs to many buttons) would be something like the Wii Nunchuck for movement and strafing combined with a mouse for aim/shooting/melee.