I prefer to refer to my french review site "gamekult" :
Heavenly sword 5
Bioshock 9
PGR4 8
CoD4 8
Halo3 7
Lair 3
Warhaxk 7
BlueDragon 6
R&C 8
Mass Effect 8
Unchartred not yet
eye of judgement 6
SMG 9
Assassin Creed 8
it sounds ok for me
not extreme score 10/10, only Bioshock and SMG at 9/10
Time to Work !