Kasz216 on 02 December 2009
| Akvod said: If you consider it a "bigger" sin to kill a 3'rd party than oneself, then it'll be a more... utilitarian... nah that's greatest utility and hapiness... Well my point is that people usually have a concept of "worse" sins. It is worse to kill 5 people than 1, ignoring utility. If it is considered worse to kill somebody else than oneself, then it'll be a better choice to kill oneself. However, that does not necessarily mean that the suicide is not morally wrong. You still "stain your soul", just not as much if you did the alternative. So it's like saying if it is a mortal sin to fuck a babyl, if the alternative is to kill the whole world. Sure, it's worse to kill the whole world, but it's still wrong to fuck a baby. If it's a matter of accountability, that's an issue of free will. Did you have any choice? Most people will say no I think... fuck I'm rambling, I fucking hate philosophy.... *taps legs because of Red Bull* Anyone want to prove the existence of an external world (as we perceive it) with me? |
Well Catholic wise I think it's simplier then that.
Suicide is considered wrong... I beleive... because God has a path for you... and by killing yourself you are deviating from the path or paths he'd wish you to follow.
Zombies would be a perversion of gods will and minions of the Devil, as such the suicide sin would be lifted since you have been forced off the paths god wanted already.
