I also noticed the XBox 360 won the first round with regard to comparing the two controllers.
I find that pretty amazing, my girlfriend had major issues with the XBox 360 controller and not at all with the PS3 controller. Although I with my big hands can manage both controllers, I prefer the PS3 controller a lot (despite never owning a PS2, which was similar).
I find it funny so many people lacking a background in ergonomics (unlike me) somehow believe Microsoft got this right. But of course, the controller of the original XBox was more sucky.







