By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
De85 on 15 November 2009
Edit Thread
MikeB said:
Kasz216 said:
Braid came out later on PS3 right?

There is your answer?

Is Resistance 1 came out today on 360 would it be rated as high as it is on PS3?

I think if it would be a new release (without the PS3 version existing), it probably would be close. I think graphics plays less of a factor with regard to that game scoring 86% on average as there were better looking games available at the time. IMO Resistance: Fall of Man to this day remains a solid FPS.

An exactly identical version would of course not be possible as the game for example includes great 7.1 audio the 360 simply isn't capable of supporting. I think some early PS3 games would potentially even have scored better on the 360, like the Motorstorm games (even with slighty downgraded graphics, controls and audio).

Really?  There is so much more quality competition now that I don't think it would get within 5% of its original score. 

That's not knocking the game, but I don't think that any game, regardless of platform or genre would/should receive the same score several years after release.

As for Braid, I think the original score was too low.  95 easily from me when it first came out.