Leaked IGN review of Modern Warfare 2

[zaMy]

Parasitic said:

Phrancheyez said:

The only undeserving games you both posted were R2 and GTAIV.  MGS4 is a 10/10, KZ2 is maybe a few tenths worse but still a 9.0+, and Uncharted 2 is very deserving of it's score.


MW:2 looks like a massive upgrade over MW, I don't know if you've been paying attention or just crying without knowing anything about the game except for it's name.  Go watch a few videos or posts on the new features.  I can't say it's a 9.5 at this point, but when I'm playing it after picking it up tomorrow, I'll be sure to come on and confirm that you're upset over something you know nothing about. 

 

So what would MGS: Peacewalker get if it was on the ps3 and it improved alot since MGS4? An 11/10?

Thanks for helping me prove my point about fanboys. I happen to own a ps3 with MGS4 and Uncharted 2. They're both great. I was making a point about how broken the scoring system was so that when a game does deserve higher than MGS4, there's actually room for it....I think it makes alota sense....

 

Did you notice that MW1 got a 9.4? If MW2 is really a massive improvement over the first, how would reviewers score it then? 9.6? 9.8? Is a massive improvement really only worth that little over the 9.4? Would MW2 really be worthy of a 9.8 if it did get one? Call of Duty 6 just might be out next year. What happens if that's also a massive improvement over MW2? IGN temporarily down due to score explosion?

I agree with you. I havent read your argument, but I like your siggy