By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Zucas on 04 November 2009
Edit Thread
DaHuuuuuudge said:
Zucas said:
Can't really decide GOTY when the year isn't over yet. I must say this does seem like a topic simply created to praise Uncharted 2 rather than to actually give an analytical account of the potential GOTY's from GI or any. Indeed creating something that is analytical and debatable in nature for the sole point of the conclusion is not logical.

As for GI I really have no idea what they will give GOTY nor am I really able to comment on what they will give it to. There are still a few games this year to come out and lots of potential from earlier on as well.

In my own lazy way, I sort of feel like I explained, only a game that gets a score of 1010 could be game of the year, because, as I stated, score = #1 proirity for game informer. I really feel that U2's closest competitor is MW2, but I feel that it will get nocked down at least .25 points because of the lack of DS on pc.

And yes, the only true way to decide is after the year ends, but I want you to predict.

While I disagree with your opinions, I am glad you have them

Well considering that is how you think it would be done, a lot of review sites/magazines, like to take their best reviewed game, put them in a pot, and decide on a level there.  I don't think it is a great way of doing it but because games are usually reviewed in relation to their platform I'm assuming this is the only "fair" way to do it.  But I still have my grievances with the system.