Your final score is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYY tooo low. It would fit right in with a VGC review.
A lot of the complaints you have with the game aren't even real complaints. How does Drake's shooting skills have anything to do with the rest of your review??? Isn't it us, the player, who shoots for Drake? Would it be better if he simply died ten minutes into the game? There are many games in which the main character overcomes tremendous odds. This is one of them.
Also, I completely disagree with you on the game length and ending. The game was longer than the first one, and did something new in almost every chapter. It also had a great deal of things you could do after the game is finished. Something like 30 skins, 7 crazy tweaks like unlimited ammo and mirror world, videos, treasures, etc.,
The ending has to be one of the funniest endings I've seen in a while. Short, sweet and straight to the point. I've seen it three times now and I laugh at their conversation every time.
This game deserves a minimum 9.5 IMO.







