| MakoInfused said: If 10 was perfection, no game in history would get a "10" simply because nothing is perfect. 10 is just an extremely enjoyable must-buy game IMO Like others have said...your reason to subtract .8 out of the score is just weak. Im not saying it deserves a 10, but if it's a 9.2, those reasons just dont seem appropriate :P
|
10 out of 10 is perfection. Now something can be perfect depending on the criteria used to evaluate perfection. But if you state negative thing in your evaluation it doesnt make sense to give 10 out of 10 after that. You need to substract at least .1 based on how it affect the overall experience or the importance of what you critizising. Perfection can be evaluate differently by different person, but 10 out of 10 always mean perfection. If you didnt substract any points, it means that it was perfect based on the criterias used to evaluate the games. Now we can question those criterias because it doesnt make sense to have that much games at or near 10. I would have probably give uncharted 2 between 9 and 9.5 and its way better than most games nowadays.
