Reasonable on 31 October 2009
Silent Hill 2 overall - the champ of real unsettling horror for me
Also,
Fear and AvP2 for FPS (well, playing as a Marine anyway)
System Shock 2 for FPS/RGP/Survival hybrid awesomeness
Dead Space was fun but didn't have depth in the end and Condemned series, while great, always seemed to miss the bullseye (but not by much).
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
