I can't award any of them gold, because that standard belongs to collections like The Orange Box and Super Mario Allstars + Super Mario World that just outshine these in sheer content and variety.
I would award each silver. The GTA game seems to have rectified some of the issues forum goers have had with GTA4 and it should get kudos for that. Metroid Prime Trilogy is three excellent games, two of which are Wii-ified control wise. God of War has a graphical boost, but considering GOW3 doesn't seem to contain much more than that itself, the games won't feel dated compared to the demo and the third's eventual release. MPT is a bit more in price, but it also offers three games.
To how valuable I see each to it's ownership as far as bragging rights go:
1. MPT
2. GOW Collection
3. GTA: Episodes from Liberty City
Tag: Became a freaking mod and a complete douche, coincidentally, at the same time.
