polezo on 13 November 2007
@ Benkenobi
That's fair, but its hard to really collect all of the GOTY's because of the different times they fall. The Joystick awards, for example, just happened recently but were too early to include games like Galaxy and Mass Effect in competition. The GDC is in Febuary, so it could include Brawl, GTA IV and Metal Gear IV in its pool of games to choose from (though the latter too are far less likely). Hence since the nominees are going to be different, its somewhat like comparing apples to oranges.
I do agree that IGN's GOTY is pretty good. I like their overall coverage, and it falls in appropriate time of the year (in December/January, I think, after all the big holiday releases).
