Edge Issue 208 Scores

[mushroomboy5]

kowenicki said:

Incubi said:
Just for reference, here's edge's reviews of main mario games:

SMW2 Yoshi's Island - 9
SM64 - 10
SM Sunshine - 9
SM Galaxy - 9
NSMB - 8
NSMB.Wii - 7

So they arent biased... they just dont think its as good.

Edge arent biased.

But you have to remember that a 7 from them isnt bad...

I agree...

Plus I think you need to put the time period that these games were released, or the console they were made for into the equation as well...Yoshi's Island was innovative for it's time, SM64 was innovative for it's time, NSMB was made for a handheld machine etc...nsmbwii is really just a retro/ds style game released on a home console(the next fully fledged mario title is SMG2)...but I'm sure it's good !!!

Mebbe they expect more than a 2d retro pastiche, esp on a home console...they gave the first galaxy a higher score after all...

But yeah a 7 from edge doesn't phase me at all...7 from them is good