By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
d21lewis on 18 October 2009
Edit Thread
Munkeh111 said:
d21lewis said:
silicon said:
^They never said it wouldn't be impossible on another console. They said the game as it exists now was designed to take advantage of the PS3 hardware and possible because they have good devs.

In other words, it would be great on ANY console but different depending on the hardware.

I refuse to let the issue go until someone agrees with me that it would be EXACTLY the same on the 360 -INCLUDING the option for motion controls, the ability to import your Uncharted 1 saves, AND the inclusion of "Triangle, Square, and Circle" buttons on the QTE's.  I will not back down.

There would be load times as they couldn't use the HDD to help stop loading times. They wouldn't have been able to stick so much in, they have said they are filling up a whole blu-ray disc. It wouldn't look as good.

It wouldn't look as good? Because of the size of the blu-ray disc?  And, the HDD is necessary to stop loading times?  The game is 10 hours long, the first time through.  And time and time again, as recently as Batman Arkham Asylum, the 360 has been able to handle games without the mandatory hardware install that the PS3 had to have.  Uncharted has a ton of making of videos on the blu-ray that you and I (despite the fact that I used my in-game currency to buy) will NEVER watch.  That's the only advantage of the blu-ray that I can see.  The graphics are great, as I will admit.  I loved the game.  But it wasn't leaps and bounds above anything we haven't seen on the 360.  No insanely varied enemy types.  No large, hulking, overly detailed animated creatures.  The place where U2 shined above all others was with its amazing voice work, characterization, and choice of camera angles.  Hardly anything hardware related.

Worse case scenario would've been a second disc with special features/multi player.



*and my previous post was a thinly veiled attempt at humor...........