Forza Motorsport 3 vs Gran Turismo 5 damage comparison

[selnor]

ultima said:

JaggedSac said:

selnor said:

JaggedSac said:
What did InsideSimRacing give Forza 3 for damage? I think it was pretty good, damage isn't just visual, there are internal things that go wrong. Such as fucking up when using the clutch.

They actually gave Damage 5/5, and said it's the best representation of damage in a game as a whole. Whether it be the user braking the clutch or visual damage.

Yeah, I remember them saying it was best in class for sim games I think.

If they gave Forza a 5, what would they give Dirt and Grid? 10/5?

No way. It's the damage as a whole for all games. Dirt 2 was great visually but absolutely sucked where it mattered. Under the hood. Grid though I thought was excellent. On the new weight system I believe it would have gotten a 5. From what I am understanding from Inside Sim Racing though is that the damage is impressive in FM3. More importantly things like misusing the clutch pedal on wheel actually destroys the clutch on your car. Real life.