Is Magna Carta 2 The Best JRPG Since Tales of Vesperia?

[selnor]

ameratsu said:

selnor said:

Akvod said:
Even if we do agree that JRPGs don't fit under the title of RPG, that only proves that it's mislabeled, not because it's a bad game.

If we mislabel GeoW as a FPS, does that mean it's a bad game since it doesn't fit the criteria of a FPS game?

I agree with this. The debate only came up because someone called Demon Souls a JRPG, when reviews have all said it's got alot of Oblivion in it. Thats all. Noone said they were bad games though.

 

[citation needed]

Please show me where reviewers say this.

Ok all may be a bad word. But the 2 reviews I read in Videogamer and computer and video games magazines explained alot of similarities to oblivion.