Tough for me to make a list honestly, but I'll give it a shot:
5. Fable 2 - I don't hate it, but I loved the first one. This one just hasn't grabbed me so far. I still have it, and I think I'll get through it eventually.
4. Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess - What an ass-ugly game! I can't believe how bad this looks, Metroid Prime looks way better than this. It's not just about graphics though, the motion controls on this game just feel so tacked-on and just pointless. I really expected perfection, because you should be able to with a Zelda game.
3. GTA4 - So much hype, such a yawner. Seriously, San Andreas is in my top 10 games of all time, and the intro scene from that game is better than 3/4 of what I experienced in GTA4.
2. Killzone 2 - I bought into the hype, paid full price for this game, and wow was it average. The character models were a resounding "OK", the color palette consisted of gray, black and more gray, and the controls were "realistic". I personally don't play games for realism, I play them to be the bassest MoFo around. Just didn't do it for me.
1. Metal Gear Solid 4 - The biggest letdown I have ever had. 4 1/2 hours of gameplay, 7 1/2 of (admittedly very good) movies. I never could get into the game, there was only about 15 mins of gameplay interrupted by 15-30 minutes of conversations with Otacon. I wouldn't trade the experience for anything, because it is fan service at it's best, but I never once thought "Oooh, that was fun!", and isn't that why we play games?







