The thread about the uncharted thread(hi nordlead!!)

[inverted3reality]

I think the point is that anything under a 8.5 is a completely unreasonable score for the game. Likewise, anything under 8.5 for any of the fine 360 exclusives is unreasonable as well.
If you score it below 8.5 it is clealy fan bias. The game is an 8 on story and graphics tech alone.