GT explains its Uncharted 2 score

[themanwithnoname]

akuseru said:

Pipedream24 said:

PullusPardus said:

leo-j said:

" No matter what, if a game is not innovative it will NEVER get a higher score than what we gave UNCHARTED 2, when a developer puts together everything that other devs have done its basically a me 2 thing, Uncharted 2 is exactly like the first game, be happy we said buy it if you have a ps3"

Gears of War 1  : 9.1

Gears of War 2 : 9.5

whats innovative about Gears 2?

 

Uncharted 1 : Single player only

Uncharted 2 : + Online ,  + coop , + matchmaking ++++++++  blah blah blah.

Guess i'll leave you alone in the dark Gametrailers

 

Horde mode.

They had horde mode in Timesplitters 2 (?) on PS2, XBOX and GC (?). So NO, not innovative.

Now I don't have a problem with a 9.3 at all, by all means it is a great score. The "problem" however is when he gives the explanation he does, and clearly shows that he has not followed that model on neither GeOW2, Halo3 nor GTA4 and possibly a lot of other games, you know he is talking shit. And then in top of that, they give a 4-6 hour, $60 expansion pack like ODST which almost show NO innovation nor improvement from it's predecessor an 8.9 you can clearly see that their review system is broken.

In addition, their Uncharted 2 review was full of (possible) spoilers... Like they almost did it on purpose because they can't be that stupid... Honestly...

My opinion on the matter, however I do not care.

A) Don't tell me you don't have a problem with the score when you've cherry picked three games that they gave a better score to than Uncharted 2 to compare it with.

B) Prove to me that the same person wrote all of those reviews. Different people review things differently.