GT explains its Uncharted 2 score

[steverhcp02]

RageBot said:

steverhcp02 said:

RageBot said:

TowlieFTW said:

Xoj said:
well halo 3 wasn't innovative, whats the score?

Forge, Screenshots, Fileshare-being able to download things from B.net, Theatre, 4 player co-op, Massive stat tracking on Bungie.net-heatmaps etc., video rendering.

 

Ignore all of those please.

Don't mind if I will, since all of these existed on the PC WWWWAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYY before bungie created the first Halo :)

Halo 3 is a console game. Its completely unfair to compare console innovation to PC innovation.

What are you serious?

How is it "innovation" to copy something that ALREADY EXISTED?!?!?!

Because of the platform.

Is Xbox live not innovative because we could game online on PC's before?

Is the Iphone or Itouch not innovative because we could game on gameboys before?

All of the things halo 3 brought that Towlie mentioned never have been done on a HOME CONSOLE, that is the innovative part, perhaps progression, but then we are just splitting hairs.

You cant just say, "ive done X before so if its done again its copied" There are many things that go into innovation.