My playthrough with Heavenly Sword

[IllegalPaladin]

Words Of Wisdom said:

Isn't the fact that you acknowledge the game would get boring if it was longer a red flag that something is wrong with the game? The staple comment of video games used to be "That was so much fun, I wish there was more." Now it's "Dang, I'm glad that game was short. I couldn't take any more of it."

That aside, it makes me sad that game developers can sell half-games these days and not only get away with it but have people praise them for it. At least Heavenly Sword lives up to the rent-only mantra it has built up.

Perhaps I should explain it. The main reason I said that is that the game and it's pacing feels about right. I'm not exactly saying that it would be terrible if it were longer and I'd definatly playthrough it a second time once I beat it because the rest of my post talked about how much I really enjoyed it (you know, incase you didn't see that).

 

It has to do with games that start to feel dragged on after a while of doing the same stuff. Heavenly Sword is a God of War clone and thus it's very heavy on the button combo mashing. God of War 1 and 2 are good games, no? However, I beat them in around 6-8 hours.

Were they fun?
-yes

Would I have liked an extra 3-4 hours of the exact same stuff (at least of the main storyline)?
-Hell no, it began to get boring of fighting the same enemies or the same groups of enemies with mashing down on the same three combos. Still, the pacing of the game was good with it's puzzles, encounters, ect and if they paced it well and balanced all the aspects of gameplay, maybe I'd feel better with more time. 

Rather than question the actual lenght of a game (and why is there a post above talking about a 40+ hour RPG, that's obviously a totally different league and tells me that maybe you've taken my post wrong) the question I'd find myself asking would be the level of replay (with all that extra content, side-quests, ect) that a game offers and that seems to be the main problem with Heavenly Sword, not exactly it's length. For example, Call of Duty 4 is about a 5-6 hour game, but it has the extra content in the multi-player that makes the shortness of the game not matter as much (unless of course you either don't have any or have a poor internet connection).

Lastly, remember that I said that I was renting it too.