Gab on 08 October 2009
| eb30577 said: Edge reviews are completely inconsistent. For example: Bioshock 8/10 Halo ODST 9/10 Oblivion 8/10 Halo 3 10/10 Fallout 3 7/10 GTA IV 10/10 Mass Effect 7/10 Gears of war 8/10 Gears of war 2 9/10 All great games but the scores just don't make sense. Their all over the place. So there you have it Gab, try to defend them now. The funny thing is this is just a small sample of the inconsistencies found among their reviews. |
Well apart from Halo that I can't really comment on (not a fan and haven't played ODST), I don't really see a problem here. Fallout 3 maybe should have been an 8, but the game was a mess. Mass Effect was good but not fantastic, 7 seems right to me. Gears of war got to high scores everwhere else because everybody was swept away by the hype/graphics, 8 is spot on. GTA IV is fantastic.
And I guess like every other publication, there are a team of people writing reviews and not just one person, so some so-called inconsistencies are natural.
