The people int his thread who think GTAIV is over-rated, but and Halo is not, need to go back and play those two games once more. Cause I would flip that one around completely. If we are to say Halo deserved its score, then GTAIV deserved to be rated as high as it is.
None of us can really know if Uncharted 2 is over-rated untill we play it. Adam Sessler was quoted as saying it is the best single player campaing hes ever played, so it's understandable that some reviewers are giving it perfect scores. We will have to wait and play it ourselves before we decide. There will definitly be people who say it is over-rated.
However, those will be the same people who think the first Uncharted was over-rated, Heavenly Sword was too short, Warhawk needed a single-player campaign, Little Big Planet was just a level creator, Killzone 2 compromised game play for graphics, Resistance needed split-screen, and MGS4 was just an interactive movie.







