Yeah a lot of those games just barely fall short of the mark but theres a few I think deserve it.
Call of Duty 2 was a awesome launch game and sadly the online was pretty "meh" while PD0 did a good job with the online portion. From a multiplayer perspective it deserves less then a 9, everywhere else It's a 9 or above.
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night is a classic no matter how old it may be
Left 4 Dead is innovative and gives a new meaning to how people enjoy a FPS. No longer do you need to slaughter eachother when you can work together and take on adapative AI.
Dead Space - Fantastic game.
Virtua Fighter 5 - A slightly late port but an Amazing fighter with online abilities. My favorite VF to boot.
Shadow Complex - Amaazing how this does not score a 90 or higher.
It's just that simple.
