I've never felt anything as comfortable as the GC controller. I only have one complaint, and that's the size of the c-stick. Would've been nicer for FPS's if it was larger.
Some more thoughts:
I'm sorry but the Dual Shock isn't very comfortable. If they swopped the d-pad and left analog it might be better-dunno.
Xbox controller S was pretty good. It fitted in nicely with the Xbox theme of more is better. X360 very cool - Love the X button and functionality. Just a little bit less comfortable than GC though.







