The fight over Darwin - Teaching evolution in schools

[Rath]

appolose said:

Rath said:

The math did work (and has been done) so can you come up with a situation that would actually meet the criteria I stated earlier?

I don't think there are any which don't violate the laws of logic.

Whether or not it did or does is not the issue.  "If it didn't" is what I'm saying (you did say it didn't have to be real observation)

If the math didn't work then we would have to change the current model of the laws of physics until the maths did work, or if there actually was a supernatural cause then science would simply leave it un-explained forever. There simply isn't a way for science to accept the supernatural that doesn't involve breaking logic.