By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Dallinor said:
Words Of Wisdom said:
Dallinor said:

Anecdotal evidence is more telling then an industry award?

I personally hate the film "A Room with a View" yet it won 3 Academy Awards.

Whats more telling and valuable of the two above?


Your post wins the Sony Ultimate Cookie King award.


Your user name is ironic really.

If you can't defend your position after making a claim in a post, don't post at all.

 


I did defend my position with my last post however not in so many words. Don't worry about it though. By now, it's very much akin to how explaining a joke will never make it funny.  Let's move on.

To start from the top, my point was that personal testimonies like the above are valuable (read: meaningful) than awards.

Your counterpoint was to show an instance where something that was personally disliked won many awards.

My point in response will now be: If you did not like the film, how meaningful are those awards to you?