^it's funny you mentioned Uncharted. I gave that game a 7/10 because it was short, the gameplay felt repetitive, and a lack of enemy variety.
I count replay value as the top of all things because you're paying for entertainment. I mentioned above that only few people would watch the Godfather in a cinema if the ticket price was $60, because they know it'll only last for a couple of hours.
Ico is an 8 or 9 if you rent it. It's a 6 or 7 if you buy it. The game is great while it lasts, but since it's short, you can't justify the purchase if you buy it.
I'm taking value as a big chunk of the review table because I'm a realistic type of guy. I'd only buy something that I know I'll keep for awhile, not just for a one time kick and then I'll resell it.







