By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

People seem to be fixated on the duration of the campaign and ignore the (reported) immersiveness and overall quality of the experience.

I'd rather watch (and re-watch) a great movie that clocks in at 75 minutes than sit through a 180 minute director's cut of the steaming pile of "Independence Day".

A long movie (experience) isn't necessarily a great one.

And, sorry, great graphics don't inherently make a game any better. Particularly in light of how many people post about their love of their PSOne and PS2 games...

"...still one of the greatest games ever" statements abound. I don't see anyone seriously suggesting that aging graphics makes those games any less fun and should drop their review score.

If it's a price issue, then just wait until the price cuts come. The game itself isn't any better or worse for being its price - a $49.99 game isn't better than a $59.99 game merely for being $10 cheaper. If price is the reason that a game is ding'd in review score, then the review score would have to be rounded up once the price dropped. I have yet to see that happen...