Mafia Round 5A - Game Thread

[trashleg]

SciFiBoy said:

Son1x said:
Hmm, what if we think like this:
In the previous games, there was always someone that mentioned they should lynch someone on the first day and he ended up getting lynched themselves (or were close). Maybe the mafia is trying to do take advantage of that and corner (=lynch) dsister (he was the first one, right?), who in this game suggested first that we lynch someone.

interesting, though, for all we know, you and he are both mafia so trying to get us to suspect others, which would be a clever tactic on your part, would it not

 
SciFiBoy, Son1x's post doesnt seem to be suggesting that dsister IS mafia, because he hasn't said whether or not the first-lynched people in the other games were townies or mafia, so there's no leaning either way, if u get my point? seems like more of an observation than an accusation to me.

but then, back to son1x's point.. the people cornering dsister are hatmoza and carl.. hatmoza seems to be trying to cause some hostility between players, i think he's mafia. my point below further adds to the suspicion. and like i mentioned, carl requested that he be lie-detected. since this IS  a plausible thing that WOULD yield results, why would he endanger himself? i know its the oldest trick in the book, but when its too possible that he'd be caught out its too big a risk.

hatmoza said:

I wouldn't say agressive. He did answer the question and countered with one... why are you so eager  to lynch someone carl?

If anything you should answer his question first. We can't afford to make a mistake so early in the game. We definately don't want to give the other side a head start.

 looks to me like hatmoza is using playground camaraderie tactics. you know, being all chummy and that.. seems rather false IMO.

Final-Fan said:

As for who to suspect, the accusations are really flying. I'm inclined to say that either Carl is mafia or some of the people who ganged up on him on Day 1 are mafia. Since I don't recall Carl really having a faction to defend him, I'll trust him today and

 and again... hatmoza was one of those people.

hatmoza said:

@ carl. All I care now is to find the mafia members by any means. I have nothing to hide I'm a townfolk and I'm going to try to beat the odds here.
Am I playing in the dark? Yes, but I have to start somewhere.
SciFiBoy : No,Yes, No
You're still getting lynched. Even if it's a mistake.

 if hatmoza was a townie, he would (should) care a hell of a lot more about making careless mistakes than he seems to be.. the whole point of the game is to not lose too many people! so every mistaken lynch is one step closer to defeat. you're making this very easy for everyone, hatmoza.

vote: hatmoza