Against the Industry (Malstrom)

[MontanaHatchet]

Khuutra said:

MontanaHatchet said:

Khuutra said:

I grant that he is egotistical, but given that he defines the "industry" as a mindset I do not think the suggestion is that radical.

The fact that gaming companies have gotten worse and need to go back to the way it was before is the heart of what he's saying. As sour as it may be in your mouth, you actually agree with him.

If he's saying that he wants the industry to die as a mindset, that's fine. However, I'd rather not see thousands of people lose their jobs. From what I read, it sounded like he was describing that the industry should fall, which I just don't want. I agree with him on some points, but we differ on many. Had Nintendo not intervened, the practices Malstrom describes might have led to the destruction of the industry. But really, the next generation should be great. As the economy improves and developers move towards cheaper development (the current development model can't be sustained), they won't need to use these measures. They're not going after used game sales and selling limited edition copies because they hate the consumer or want to rip us off, it's just because they need the money. They're not greedy, they're just struggling.

I've never liked Malstrom for his arrogant attitude, and it's actually funny to see how bad it's gotten.

You need to read the whole thing. Part of what he dislikes about the industry is that it's so easy for people to lose their jobs, because there is an artificial turnover rate created whenever people try to buck trends and create somethign that's actually new. It's like the heead of Activision said vis-a-vis taking the fu out of making games: Maelstrom detests that mindset.

Maelstrom would argue that a large part of their struggles is because they are greedy, and consumers are rejecting their valuee propositions over and over.

He may be arrogant, but that does not change the core of what he's saying.

I did read that part. He says that people lose their jobs because young employees enter the workforce and replace them. That's normal for any industry. I have no idea what you just said about Activision, but I'm sure he detests a lot of things. He can call the industry greedy, but then you'd have to wonder if what he says is largely true. If developers mainly cared about the money, would there be a stream of great games like the ones we're seeing today? There's always going to be a lot of games that are ripoffs or games that don't provide a lot of value or games that are just like every other one out there, that's not exclusive to this generation. In fact, it was actually pretty common in the older generations, or those good old says.