Hidalgo on 13 September 2009
Pick Folklore. It's a great game, with a great plot that was underrated for being PS3 Only. Also Heavenly Sword and MS:PR are a great choice.
I loved Heavenly Sword, and MS is quite funny. Also, go for PixelJunk Monsters. Funny as hell and it have trophies, custom soundtracks (though the original is great), coop...
