No I'm not, any living thing, instantly destroyed and recreated would behave in the same way. All creatures are simply interactions of matter and energy as far as I can see.
You're not even arguing about living things, PS3's and Cavaliers are not relevant to this because they do not have a consciousness which is what this debate is about.
Can you reply to the hypothetical situation of destruction and recreation in one Planck time in exactly the same state? Because I cannot think of any answer to it.








