Aj_habfan on 10 September 2009
| Kasz216 said: Hm. Got to the last question on the God thing. Though the result doesn't really make sense. Somehow saying god can change things so that the impossible is possible makes it so you can't have a rational discussion about god. I don't get it. |
I'm with you on this.
1 bitten bullet for me:
"You claimed earlier that any being which it is right to call God must want there to be as little suffering in the world as possible. But you say that God could make it so that everything now considered sinful becomes morally acceptable and everything that is now considered morally good becomes sinful. What this means is that God could make the reduction of suffering a sin... yet you've said that God must want to reduce suffering. There is a way out of this, but it means biting a bullet. So you've got to make a choice:"
I still don't think it's a contradiction, but I'll be aware of this.
