Does the PS3 have the best 2010 lineup?

[starcraft]

Torillian said:

starcraft said:

Kantor said:

Slimebeast said:
No it doesn't. The best lineup for 2010 is on the X360.

Alan Wake
Fable III
Halo: Reach

Nothing can touch that combo of pure gold.

The best lineup for 2010 is on the PS3.

Heavy Rain
God of War III
The Last Guardian

Nothing can touch that combo of pure gold.

See, you can do it for any console.

Heavy Rain is from a genre so niche it is ridiculous.  It's appeal is EXTREMELY limited.  Don't get me wrong, I'll be there day one.  But I'll be about the only one lol.

The Last Guardian has exactly the same problem.

God of War 3 will be stunning, but again, only around 3 million people will ever know this.  The lowest selling game in Slimebeasts list will probably sell that.

Does those games not selling as well make them less fun for you?  Do you really need to know that there are millions of others that are playing the game at the same time as you before you enjoy it?  Do you think that the fact that Fable 2 sold more than SotC comes even close to being evidence that it is better? 

Why people bring sales into a discussion about general game quality I'll never understand.  Those three 360 games could stand on their own just from quality, you don't need to make excuses for them.

But a game being Niche DOES have an effect on it's perceived quality, if it's scope to be enjoyed by people is limited.

But so we're clear, Fable 2 is better.