In my opinion:
Uncharted has amazing textures, vibrant colours, nice looking water, though the cutscenes are prerendered and the game has quite noticeable tearing and pop ups.
MGS4 has amazing character models, fully realtime cutscenes that have the best graphical quality, direction and mo capped animations i have --ever-- seen, great pp effects, exceptionally looking water and superb water interaction, zero tearings or pop ups, generally excelent framerate with much more going on, octocamo > bread.
MGS4 wins, but not really because of it's technological achievements, but mostly because of the almost overwhelming atention to details and because of how those little gestures and interactions that come naturally and we take for granted in movies are so flawlessly reproduced. God trully is in the details ;)
"You have the right to the remains of a silent attorney"
