Vgchartzville's Mafia Round 3 - Game Thread

[Words Of Wisdom]

dtewi said:

Khuutra said:

We're not going to hang Soleron today. That is not on the agenda.

I am a Townie, 100% positive of my own role. Craan, I want you to scan me tonight. If I come back Mafia, then you're insane, and Soleron is not necessarily Mafia - this doesn't clear him, it just means that you might see everyone as being Mafia, instead of seeing them in reverse roles. I'm not sure where we'll go from there.

If I come back Townie, then we can lynch the Hell out of Soleron.

Yeesh, was it a good idea to state your role to Craan? He can just lie.

Okay, I have a theory.

Say Khuutra and Soleron are both mafia.  Khuutra convinces everyone that he's a townsfolk and then prevents Soleron from being lynched while also convincing Craan to investigate him.  If Khuutra comes back as Mafia (and he would) then Khuutra concludes that Craan is insane and that both he and Soleron are innocent.

So now Khuutra has convinced everyone that both he and Soleron are non-Mafia, neither of them are lynched, and we all die.

I propose that we lynch Soleron and have Craan investigate Khuutra.  If Craan is sane then we'll find out when we lynch Soleron.  Then we can judge from that how to view Khuutra's result.