Well when I read the title of this thread I thought to myself Halo 3.
Many are referencing 'hype' as the reason their choice game was overrated.
However, I don't see that as the definition of overrated.
To me overrated means that the game is given higher reviews or grades than it deserves.
After thinking some more I would add a couple to the list
- Halo 3 is overrated but Halo 1 is a great game that got good reviews.
- GTAIV is overrated but GTA3 and Vice City are great games with good reviews
- God of War 2 is overrated but God of War 1 is a great game with good reviews
This is all just my opinion, the games aren't 'bad' just not nearly as good as the reviews made them out to be.... hence 'overrated' :)
Current Favorites:
Wii - Muramasa, MH3, Metroid Trilogy, RS2, Okami, RE4, COD, Dead Space, Scarface
PC - L4D, TF2, BFBC2, Killing Floor, Aquaria, Warsow, many UDK indie games
Mods - MechWarrior:Living Legends, Star Wars: Galatic Warfare, PVKII, Goldeneye Source, L4D mods
PS3 - Demon Souls, Way of the Samurai 3
Social Modding Club: ModDb | Steam
