Zucas on 06 August 2009
Gears of War 1. Never played a game that had such a high critical rating, loads of GOTY awards, and such praise from players to actually be so disturbed by it all. Generally with the highly rated games I could see how they got that rating even if I personally didn't like it... not with Gears of War. Gears of War 2, though, was an excellent game which I play quite often... but the first was a work in progress that was fixed by the second.
