Is Halo CE is ONE of the best FPS ever but not THE Best FPS ever?

[IllegalPaladin]

uadfa said:

disolitude said:

Barozi said:
1. Half-Life 2
2. Halo CE

Yes it IS that easy.

Are we comparing campaigns only? Cause they are pretty close...with maybe the slight advantage to HL2 (and a 3 year later start) However Halo multiplayer should give it the edge in this battle.

Except Half-Life 2's deathmatch is utterly forgettable.

Half-Life dea- what?

I believe it was thrown together at the last second anyway because people were yelling about it. When it comes to Valve and multiplayer, it's better to look at their real multiplayer games such as Counter-Strike and Team Fortress 2.