Partly a good idea, partly a bad one. Its a good idea since its very consumer-centric (radically consumer-centric, even), but its a bad idea because the consumers often don't really know what they want. Imagine a world without Wind Waker, which is what you would get if this kind of idea prevailed. Very few people knew they wanted Wind Waker when it was originally shown, many very loudly stated their desire for it to go away.
In short, this idea could lead to tremendous creative stagnation, since most only want to invest in what they know.

Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.







