Is Halo CE is ONE of the best FPS ever but not THE Best FPS ever?

[disolitude]

Boutros said:

uadfa said:

Boutros said:
No... I still think Goldeneye is THE best FPS but Halo is not too far along with Half-Life 2 and CoD4.

GoldenEye is outdated and hasn't aged well at all, the controls are stiff and clunky compared to Halo.

Half-Life 2 is better than Halo but COD4 is WAY inferior, it's just a shallow shooting gallery with 100% scripted A.I. and has no replay value in the single-player. Playing on multiple difficulty settings just makes COD4 tedious and frustrating than challenging. Not to mention the multiplayer is unbalanced and takes no skill to play unlike Halo CE.

You have to consider the impact the game had when it came out. Goldeneye was so innovative for it's time.

I actually highly disagree with you about the replay value of the single player in Cod4. It's one of the most engaging and challenging FPS experience I ever had.

I agree with what uadfa said about COD4...about it being slightly repettitive...and scripted. I mean...howmany times can they give you the "get rocket launcher and destroy tank to move on" task.

But I do agree with you that the sheer tension of that game puts it on the best FPS games list. It just lacks the freedom games like Halo and HL offer.