By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Khuutra said:
SciFiBoy said:
Khuutra said:

So you're saying you do not prefer the style, which is entirely different from saying that the animation is in some way lacking in comparison to another example of the same style. Which is to say, you either did not say what you meant, or you do not mean what you say. Possibly both!

I'm not asking you to explain why you do or don't like it, I'm aksing you to explain how you find it lacking in any sense approaching objective criticism. Because I can say, as close to objectively as such things can come, that that sequence is still arguably the most beautiful piece of animation I've ever seen. It's still almost impossible to tell where they use CG.

i meant what i said, i neither like nor dislike the animation, i have seen animation that i like more, im a little puzzeled how anyone cant understand that.

im not an expert on an animation, nor would i claim to be, so i have no way of judging how well made it is, even if i did, thats not gonna change how i like how it looks now is it?

So we are in agreement that the animation is not "meh", but rather that the style does not run according to your tastes. Right?

yes