Why Do People Like Disney So Much?

[Khuutra]

SciFiBoy said:

Khuutra said:

Yeah, I'm asking you to qualify it. In what way could that animation be improved? Just from an aesthetic perspective, in what sense is it lacking? Where have you seen better in that style, exactly? How can you possibly consider it middle of the road? What perspective do you have where that kind of judgement is considered legitimate?

just how it looks to me, i like the animation in The Simpsons and anime i watch better, is that a crime now?

as for how qualified i am to make that judgement, as were talking asthetics, surely, there is no-one better qualified than myself to judge what i do or dont like?

So you're saying you do not prefer the style, which is entirely different from saying that the animation is in some way lacking in comparison to another example of the same style. Which is to say, you either did not say what you meant, or you do not mean what you say. Possibly both!

I'm not asking you to explain why you do or don't like it, I'm aksing you to explain how you find it lacking in any sense approaching objective criticism. Because I can say, as close to objectively as such things can come, that that sequence is still arguably the most beautiful piece of animation I've ever seen. It's still almost impossible to tell where they use CG.