DirtyP2002:
To be fair, your list is hardly balanced, though.
You count things like Lips for the 360, but not games like Demon's Souls, MLB, Cross Edge and Supercar for the PS3.
Furthermore, you put bad points against just about all the PS3 games you listed, but didn't put any similar remarks against the 360 lineup when they have exactly the same problems (and in a couple of cases, have the same problem even worse).
(Also, why would you doubt MAG's release date, when it was given that date less than a month ago? You may as well doubt L4D2's or Splinter Cell's.)
Not to mention that a more cynical gamer might call L4D2 and Halo 3: ODST expansion packs masquerading as full-priced retail games.
Personally, I think 2009 is pretty much a draw between the PS3 and 360, and which line-up you prefer is gonna come down to the types of games you like.
The Wii has a killer line up, though. I think it might actually have the best one this year, looking at that list.
