I think it's foolish to right-out believe or get on any one side. Obviously ID does not have enough evidence, and Evolution Theory is reaching pretty far to try and explain things we simply can't.
Yes there is variance, mutation, as well as survival of the fittest, but to what extent? Were you there when life started? Have you observed the the evolution of one species into another? No, so stop being so arrogant about your so-called evidence. We don't know how life started, all you can do is speculate with what little you do know to make it seem like it supports such assumed ideas.
Truth is, we don't know. Not saying it won't be discovered in the future or when we die. But don't step further than what is clear, and leave the rest as speculation. Why believe something you haven't experienced? On top of that, History has shown deceit in science and religion constantly, so I don't see why it would be any different.
Humans aren't that smart, that they can understand everything there is in the universe, and I think it's that weakness that drives people to want to be able to know.
My verdict: Don't believe everything you hear. Check it out for yourself. You can have your penchants, but it's foolish to overstep your personal experiences and understandings.
There is not enough evidence to support 100% of evolution and atheism, only certain obvious parts, regardless of how 'convinving' or 'factual' some say some is. ID is no better, because it clearly has almost no concrete evidence.
Solution? Agnosticism.
ps- my first post. :P Hope Im not offending anyone.
