I definitely agree the community won't be as extensive or important as LBP or UT2k4/UT3 but I do think that its worth a second consideration once more is known. If the tools for portal end up being lackluster I will completely agree with your score actually. And as of right now I do agree with the score.
But for me, I am reserving final judgment on the "Lasting Appeal" until after I get a good look at those tools and have a chance to see the volume and quality of maps being put out. I won't try to say its guaranteed to be a huge successful community, but at the same time I am not ruling it out yet either, not to suggest that you are. But that does leads me back to my initial point in my first post of the thread. Which is, I think you should at least revisit the score after the community has a chance to get going. It may not change your mind at all, it might lessen your score as you realize some of the fun was hype and newness, but all of those are fair factors imo.
Anyways, I think I have turned this conversation far away from its original intent as it is, so I will leave it at that.
 |
| To Each Man, Responsibility |
